Skip to content

Thrift vs Consignment vs Vintage vs Buy-Sell-Trade Stores

By Thrift Stores USA ยท Updated November 2026

Engraving of a man's lace-up ankle shoe with a checked cloth top
Men's lace shoe. Sears, Roebuck & Co. catalog, 1902.

Which store to use

Shop donated goods at a thrift store and older pieces at a vintage shop. To sell clothes for cash or store credit the same day, take them to a buy-sell-trade store. A consignment shop pays you a share of the sale price after your item sells.

Every store sets its own terms, so call yours before you carry anything in.

What the four types are

A thrift store sells donated goods. Goodwill Northern New England prices each item to maximize its value and spends the money on its programs.

At a Goodwill Northern New England Buy The Pound outlet, you pay by the pound. Read how outlets and bin stores work, or browse thrift outlets by state.

A buy-sell-trade store pays for goods it buys from the public. Plato's Closet in Utica, Michigan says it pays cash on the spot for the items it can take, and lets you trade for items in the store.

This directory uses "consignment shop" for a store that sells items for their owners and shares the sale price.

Current Boutique, with stores in Virginia and Washington, DC, pays 50 percent of the final sale price on each item that sells. Crossroads Trading is a buy-sell-trade chain that also takes consignment on luxury, collectible or designer goods, and it pays 50 to 70 percent depending on the selling price.

Lucky Vintage Seattle consigns select items it prices at $500 or more and pays a 50 percent split. Little Love Resale in Canby, Oregon pays 40 percent on items priced $99.99 and lower and 50 percent on items over $100.

This directory calls a store vintage when its name says vintage or retro. Debutante Clothing, which does its buying at its Downtown Pomona location, defines vintage as items at least 20 years old. WyCo Vintage, which buys old shirts at its Kansas City, Missouri and Overland Park, Kansas stores, says 20+ years is its only rule. Ask your shop for its own rule.

Lucky Vintage Seattle and Mercy Vintage price each item at fair market value, which reflects rarity, desirability and condition. These shops pay a share of the price they expect to sell an item for, and more in store credit than as a payout. Lucky Vintage Seattle and Debutante Clothing pay 30 percent as a payout or 50 percent in store credit. Mercy Vintage pays 35 percent as a payout or 45 percent in store credit.

Who owns the goods and who pays you

Four store types compared
TypeWho owns the goodsIf you bring goods in
ThriftThe store, after you donateA receipt on request, with no value assigned (Goodwill Northern New England)
ConsignmentYou, until the item sells40 to 70 percent of the sale price, after it sells (Little Love Resale, Current Boutique, Crossroads Trading)
Buy-sell-tradeThe store, once it buys25 percent of the selling price in cash, or 50 percent in trade (Buffalo Exchange)
VintageDepends on the shop30 percent of resale value as a payout, or 50 percent in store credit (Lucky Vintage Seattle, Debutante Clothing)

The stores in parentheses published these rates. Ask your own store for its rate.

Which type pays up front

Buffalo Exchange, Uptown Cheapskate and Plato's Closet in Utica, Michigan pay at the counter. Buffalo Exchange tells sellers to bring clothes into a store and get paid, and Uptown Cheapskate offers immediate cash or store credit for accepted items.

Expect the buyer to turn some items down. Plato's Closet in Utica, Michigan looks for items from original stores within the past 12 to 18 months, in styles that teenagers and young adults want.

Consignment shops pay after the sale. Crossroads Trading says you get paid when the items sell instead of right away, and Little Love Resale deposits funds into your consignor account when an item has sold. Lucky Vintage Seattle pays its split once the item sells in its store.

Little Love Resale keeps an item 60 days and gives you 7 more days to claim it. It takes ownership of unclaimed items to discount and donate. Ask your own shop how long it keeps your items and when it pays.

Before you bring goods in

Uptown Cheapskate and Lucky Vintage Seattle's University District location take sellers without an appointment. Call any other store and ask whether it needs one.

Decide before you donate. Goodwill Northern New England says it cannot promise to recover an item once you donate it.

How this directory assigns the labels

The directory reads each store's name and chain. A store counts as vintage when its name says vintage or retro, and as a consignment shop when its name says consign. A buy-sell-trade store has a name or chain on the directory's list of resale chains.

Each count below covers only labeled stores. A consignment shop without "consign" in its name gets no label and no count. A store with two labels counts under each. Outlets and donation drop-offs get none.

More stores and guides

Browse thrift store chains. To give goods away, read where to donate clothes and household goods or find donation drop-off locations. To buy furniture from these stores, read how to furnish a home secondhand.

Sources