Skip to content

Thrift stores in Fishers, IN

Fishers has 5 listings: 4 thrift stores and 1 donation drop-off. 3 belong to chains and 2 are independent.

4 stores with posted hours.

Stores with posted hours

Donation drop-off

Drop-off only. Nothing is for sale at these locations.All drop-offs in Indiana

Thrift store hours in Fishers

Eastern time
Open Sundays
3 of 4 stores: Goodwill, Goodwill Store, Plato's Closet
Open until 7 PM or later
Hours by day for 4 stores in Fishers
StoreMondayTuesdayWednesdayThursdayFridaySaturdaySunday
Goodwill9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
11 AM to
7 PM
Goodwill Store9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
11 AM to
7 PM
Plato's Closet10 AM to
9 PM
10 AM to
9 PM
10 AM to
9 PM
10 AM to
9 PM
10 AM to
9 PM
10 AM to
9 PM
11 AM to
6 PM
Wheeler Mission Store9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
10 AM to
8 PM
Closed

Hours last updated Nov 5, 2026.

Nearby cities

Frequently asked questions

How many thrift stores are in Fishers, Indiana?
There are 5 thrift stores listed in Fishers, Indiana.
Are any Fishers thrift stores open on Sundays?
3 stores are open on Sundays in Fishers.
Do Fishers thrift stores accept donations?
3 stores accept donations in Fishers.