Thrift stores in Bay Shore, NY
Bay Shore has 1 listing: a thrift store. It's independent.
1 store with posted hours.
The map didn't load. Every store is in the list below.
Stores with posted hours
No stores with posted hours match these filters.Clear filters
Thrift store hours in Bay Shore
Eastern time| Store | MondayToday | TuesdayToday | WednesdayToday | ThursdayToday | FridayToday | SaturdayToday | SundayToday |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop | 9:15 AM to 7 PM | 9:15 AM to 7 PM | 9:15 AM to 7 PM | 9:15 AM to 7 PM | 9:15 AM to 7 PM | 9:30 AM to 7 PM | 10 AM to 6 PM |
Hours last updated Nov 5, 2026.
Thrift stores near Bay Shore
- Savers3.8 mi478a Union Blvd, West Islip, NYOpenCloses soonClosedOpens today at 9 AM
Savers customers buy secondhand clothing and furniture at 478a Union Blvd in West Islip, New York. Donors can bring donations, and the store is wheelchair accessible.
- Savers6.2 mi755 Larkfield Rd, Commack, NYOpenCloses soonClosedOpens today at 9 AM
Savers customers buy secondhand footwear and clothing at 755 Larkfield Rd in Commack, New York. You can bring donations, and the store is wheelchair accessible.
- Plato's Closet6.3 miBuy-sell-trade6153 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NYOpenCloses soonClosedOpens today at 10 AM
Teens and young adults buy and sell secondhand clothing at Plato's Closet, 6153 Jericho Tpke in Commack, New York. The store is wheelchair accessible.
Nearby cities
Frequently asked questions
- How many thrift stores are in Bay Shore, New York?
- There is 1 thrift store listed in Bay Shore, New York.
- Are any Bay Shore thrift stores open on Sundays?
- 1 store is open on Sundays in Bay Shore.