Skip to content

Thrift stores in Middletown, NY

Middletown has 4 listings: 4 thrift stores. 2 belong to chains and 2 are independent.

4 stores with posted hours.

Stores with posted hours

Thrift store hours in Middletown

Eastern time
Open until 7 PM or later
None of the 4 stores list a close at 7 PM or later.
Hours by day for 4 stores in Middletown
StoreMondayTuesdayWednesdayThursdayFridaySaturdaySunday
Goodwill Nynj Store & Donation Center10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
Lovely LadiesClosed10 AM to
2 PM
Closed10 AM to
4 PM
10 AM to
4 PM
ClosedClosed
The Salvation Army10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
Closed
Your Treasure Shop11 AM to
5 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
10 AM to
5 PM
12 PM to
3 PM

Hours last updated Nov 5, 2026.

Thrift stores near Middletown

Nearby cities

Frequently asked questions

How many thrift stores are in Middletown, New York?
There are 4 thrift stores listed in Middletown, New York.
Are any Middletown thrift stores open on Sundays?
2 stores are open on Sundays in Middletown.
Do Middletown thrift stores accept donations?
2 stores accept donations in Middletown.