Skip to content

Thrift stores in Lancaster, OH

Lancaster has 10 listings: 10 thrift stores. 2 belong to chains and 8 are independent.

10 stores with posted hours.

Thrift store hours in Lancaster

Eastern time
Open Sundays
4 of 10 stores
Open until 7 PM or later
Hours by day for 10 stores in Lancaster
StoreMondayTuesdayWednesdayThursdayFridaySaturdaySunday
Bargain BoutiqueClosedClosedClosed10 AM to
2 PM
10 AM to
2 PM
10 AM to
2 PM
Closed
Furniture with a Heart - Lancaster10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
Good Neighbor Thrift Store11 AM to
5 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
ClosedClosedClosed11 AM to
5 PM
Goodwill9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
12 PM to
6 PM
Gracehaven New and UsedClosedClosed9:30 AM to
3:30 PM
Closed9:30 AM to
3:30 PM
9:30 AM to
3:30 PM
Closed
Habitat for Humanity ReStore10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
9 AM to
5 PM
Closed
Ohio Thrift Store9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
Saint Vincent de Paul Thrift Store9 AM to
4:45 PM
9 AM to
4:45 PM
9 AM to
4:45 PM
9 AM to
4:45 PM
9 AM to
4:45 PM
9 AM to
3:15 PM
Closed
Sparkle and Rust LLCClosedClosedClosed10 AM to
4 PM
10 AM to
4 PM
10 AM to
4 PM
Closed
The Salvation Army10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
Closed

Hours last updated Nov 5, 2026.

Thrift crawls in Lancaster

Each group has 3 or more stores within a mile of each other. Open a group in the route planner to set the order and get directions.

  1. N Memorial Dr

    1. Furniture with a Heart - Lancaster
    2. Ohio Thrift Store
    3. Goodwill
    4. Habitat for Humanity ReStore
    5. Good Neighbor Thrift Store

    5 stops · 1.1 mi total

    Every stop is open Monday to Wednesday.

    Plan this route: N Memorial Dr
  2. Around Sparkle and Rust LLC

    1. The Salvation Army
    2. Gracehaven New and Used
    3. Sparkle and Rust LLC
    4. Saint Vincent de Paul Thrift Store

    4 stops · 1.4 mi total

    Every stop is open Friday and Saturday.

    Plan this route: Around Sparkle and Rust LLC

Nearby cities

Frequently asked questions

How many thrift stores are in Lancaster, Ohio?
There are 10 thrift stores listed in Lancaster, Ohio.
Are any Lancaster thrift stores open on Sundays?
4 stores are open on Sundays in Lancaster.
Do Lancaster thrift stores accept donations?
5 stores accept donations in Lancaster.