Skip to content

Thrift stores in Buffalo, NY

Buffalo has 23 listings: 23 thrift stores. 9 belong to chains and 14 are independent.

23 stores with posted hours.

Stores with posted hours

Thrift store hours in Buffalo

Eastern time
Open Sundays
9 of 23 stores
Open until 7 PM or later
Hours by day for 23 stores in Buffalo
StoreMondayTuesdayWednesdayThursdayFridaySaturdaySunday
AMVETS Thrift Store9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
10 AM to
6 PM
Buffalo ReUseClosedClosed9 AM to
4 PM
Closed9 AM to
4 PM
9 AM to
4 PM
Closed
Catwalk Consignment BoutiqueClosed11:30 AM to
5 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
11:30 AM to
6 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
11 AM to
4 PM
Closed
Consignment On MainClosed11 AM to
5 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
Closed
Fistful of VintageClosedClosedClosed12 PM to
7 PM
12 PM to
7 PM
12 PM to
7 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
Goodwill2625 Delaware Ave10 AM to
7 PM
10 AM to
7 PM
10 AM to
7 PM
10 AM to
7 PM
10 AM to
7 PM
10 AM to
7 PM
10 AM to
5 PM
Goodwill3637 Union Rd10 AM to
8 PM
10 AM to
8 PM
10 AM to
8 PM
10 AM to
8 PM
10 AM to
8 PM
10 AM to
8 PM
10 AM to
5 PM
Goodwill1119 William St8 AM to
4 PM
8 AM to
4 PM
8 AM to
4 PM
8 AM to
4 PM
8 AM to
4 PM
ClosedClosed
Habitat For Humanity Restore - SouthClosed10 AM to
5 PM
10 AM to
5 PM
10 AM to
5 PM
10 AM to
5 PM
10 AM to
5 PM
Closed
Hearts Thrift Store2217 Sheridan Dr9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
Closed
Hearts Thrift Store890 Tonawanda StClosed10 AM to
3 PM
ClosedClosed10 AM to
3 PM
10 AM to
3 PM
Closed
Hertel Home ConsignmentClosed10 AM to
5 PM
10 AM to
5 PM
10 AM to
5 PM
10 AM to
5 PM
10 AM to
5 PM
Closed
Ladies Of Charity Thrift Store - Catholic Charities10 AM to
2 PM
10 AM to
2 PM
10 AM to
2 PM
10 AM to
2 PM
10 AM to
2 PM
ClosedClosed
My Cuzin Vintage12 PM to
8 PM
12 PM to
8 PM
12 PM to
8 PM
12 PM to
8 PM
12 PM to
8 PM
11 AM to
8 PM
11 AM to
5 PM
Once Upon A Child- Blasdell, NY10 AM to
8 PM
10 AM to
8 PM
10 AM to
8 PM
10 AM to
8 PM
10 AM to
8 PM
10 AM to
8 PM
11 AM to
6 PM
Queen City Vintage12 PM to
7 PM
Closed12 PM to
7 PM
12 PM to
7 PM
12 PM to
8 PM
11 AM to
8 PM
Closed
Savers9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
9 AM to
9 PM
10 AM to
7 PM
Scoop ShopClosedClosed12 PM to
5 PM
1 PM to
6 PM
12 PM to
5 PM
12 PM to
5 PM
12 PM to
5 PM
Second Chic11 AM to
6 PM
11 AM to
6 PM
11 AM to
6 PM
11 AM to
6 PM
11 AM to
6 PM
11 AM to
6 PM
12 PM to
5 PM
St. Vincent de Paul Discount Store10 AM to
3 PM
10 AM to
3 PM
10 AM to
3 PM
10 AM to
3 PM
10 AM to
3 PM
ClosedClosed
The Salvation Army7000 Transit Rd9 AM to
6 PM
9 AM to
6 PM
9 AM to
6 PM
9 AM to
6 PM
9 AM to
6 PM
9 AM to
6 PM
Closed
The Salvation Army1089 Niagara Falls Blvd9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
9 AM to
8 PM
Closed
The Serendipity ShoppeClosedClosed12 PM to
5 PM
12 PM to
5 PM
12 PM to
5 PM
12 PM to
5 PM
Closed

Hours last updated between Nov 5 and Nov 11, 2026.

Thrift crawls in Buffalo

Each group has 3 or more stores within a mile of each other. Open a group in the route planner to set the order and get directions.

  1. Elmwood Ave

    1. Fistful of Vintage
    2. Second Chic
    3. Scoop Shop
    4. Queen City Vintage

    4 stops · 0.8 mi total

    Every stop is open Thursday to Saturday.

    Plan this route: Elmwood Ave
  2. Around St. Vincent de Paul Discount Store

    1. St. Vincent de Paul Discount Store
    2. My Cuzin Vintage
    3. The Serendipity Shoppe

    3 stops · 0.9 mi total

    Every stop is open Wednesday to Friday.

    Plan this route: Around St. Vincent de Paul Discount Store
  3. Around Goodwill

    1. AMVETS Thrift Store
    2. Goodwill (2625 Delaware Ave)
    3. Hertel Home Consignment

    3 stops · 1.5 mi total

    Every stop is open Tuesday to Saturday.

    Plan this route: Around Goodwill

Specialty stores in Buffalo

Nearby cities

Frequently asked questions

How many thrift stores are in Buffalo, New York?
There are 23 thrift stores listed in Buffalo, New York.
Are any Buffalo thrift stores open on Sundays?
9 stores are open on Sundays in Buffalo.
Do Buffalo thrift stores accept donations?
8 stores accept donations in Buffalo.